With Lana Turner in the title role and supporting help from John Forsythe, Constance Bennett, Ricardo Montalban, Burgess Meredith, and Keir Dullea, 1966's Madame X is not only my favorite Lana Turner film but my favorite film of the 1960's and among my top 7 movies of all-time. It's an incredibly beautiful, heart-tugging movie...the one I consider to be the tearjerker of all tearjerkers (though Gary Cooper's Ten North Frederick is right up there too). It doesn't just cause me to weep...but to sob...almost to the point that I can barely breathe. Sometimes, I pop the movie into the player and then fast-forward to the final 30 minutes just so I can sob my heart out. Strange, yes...but the absolute truth.
The story is about Holly Anderson (Lana), a young woman who has married into a rich and powerful family. Her husband, Clay (John Forsythe), has political aspirations and an extremely controlling mother (Constance Bennett) who wants to be sure her son becomes all that he aspires to be. Although Holly and Clay seem happy and even have a son early into their marriage, Clay travels a great deal, leaving Holly very lonely. Her mother-in-law, however, tells Holly that she simply must not sit home and long for Clay...that she has a role to fulfill...that she must continue to be seen socially.
Holly begins to attend social functions with another man (Ricardo Montalban), and eventually he falls in love with her. When Holly informs him she cannot see him anymore, they fight, and he tumbles down a flight of stairs, dying immediately. Mother-in-law insists that since it looks like Holly killed him, a scandal will ensue, thus ruining Clay's political future. Determining that the best way to protect her son and grandson from Holly's "indiscretion" is to get Holly out of their lives, mother-in-law promises to cover everything up if Holly will just disappear forever. So...at mother-in-law's urging and with her help, Holly "dies" in a tragic boat accident and then goes to Europe, where mother-in-law sends money for her support.
At the time I first discovered Madame X, I didn't profess to be a huge Lana Turner fan; in fact, I really didn't care for her that much. While I loved the movie and the title character, Lana herself did nothing for me. Since then, though, I've come to love Lana and now deem her among my five favorite actresses of all time. I truly believe her performance in Madame X has to be the finest performance of her career. She is completely brilliant here...very definitely worthy of an Academy Award nomination, which, unbelievably, she did not receive.
It has recently come to my awareness that there is a 1937 version of Madame X, with Gladys George in the title role. I would love an opportunity to see it and to compare the two films.
Since Madame X is out on DVD, it ought to be fairly easy to track down a copy. Try to see it if you can, as it really is an amazingly beautiful, heart-tugging movie which I highly recommend.
Happy viewing!!




i have not seen this version but i do love Lana Turner! i too did not really like her much at first either but she grew on me, especially after seeing her deliciously sexy performance in Johnny Eager! I recently saw the Gladys George version and have also seen the even earlier Ruth Chatterton version of Madame X so i would love to catch this one someday and compare. The Ruth version is a terrible film, static and dull and sloooooow as all get out, but the Gladys George version is very good! Another very "Madame X" type film is "Frisco Jenny" with Ruth Chatterton directed by William Wellman, an excellent picture well-worth seeing if you can catch it!
ReplyDeleteAh, "Johnny Eager," also starring Robert Taylor, whom I adore. It's been awhile since I've seen that film. No doubt, Lana was sexy in that film. Actually, I think there was a sexiness to her in nearly every film she ever made...beginning with her first screen role as a girl at a soda fountain counter in "They Won't Forget." And who could forget how sensual she was in "The Postman Always Rings Twice." She was an exquisitely beautiful and sexy woman.
DeleteThanks for the information about the Ruth Chatterton version of "Madame X." I don't believe I've ever seen any of Miss Chatterton's films...I don't even know anything about her, except that she was once married to George Brent. I will take your word on her version being terrible and not seek it out, though I do hope to catch the Gladys George version and also the "Frisco Jenny" film you mentioned. I am always a sucker for tearjerkers!
Ruth was one of the stage people wooed to hollywood when the talkies came into vogue. She started at Paramount but moved to WB in the early 30's. (legend has it paramount execs sent her to Clara Bow's house to help her with her diction! apparently Clara didnt take kindly to this and did not answer her door, or something along those lines) she did not have a very long career but is in some very worthwhile pictures, the aforementioned 'Frisco Jenny', then 'Lily Turner' also directed by Wellman (and co-starring George Brent), the classic 'Female' (Brent again!), 'the Rich are Always with Us' (Brent and early Bette Davis) and her best film, 'Dodsworth' which is a must see for any classic film lover, period! the Gladys George version was a must see for me because Warren William is in it and I will watch ANYTHING he is in!
Deleteyes Lana in Postman is rather unforgettable, as is Garfield and that sultry Audrey Totter as well!
Artman, "Dodsworth" is on the TCM schedule for next Tuesday, February 26th. I am going to DVR it...and if I run into a problem with too much in the DVR (which is often the case on Mondays and Tuesdays), I am going to pull the "mom card" and trump my kids' shows. Our DVR only accommodates 2 channels at a time, and my kids put their things in weeks in advance. Sometimes when I go to set up a movie, I get the little blurb telling me that there is a conflict and that I will either have to cancel my new request, or cancel one of the 2 shows already set up. Usually, I will just skip it and let my kids' shows go on. But with "Dodsworth," I am going to use my parental authority! I've heard so many great things about that film, so I definitely want to see it.
DeleteHopefully, TCM will air "Frisco Jenny" one day soon.
This film is a good one! I need to borrow my mom's DVD sometime soon!
ReplyDeleteYes, do!
DeleteThis movie is so heartbreaking, but wonderful to watch. It was a great vehicle to show the talents of Lana Turner.
ReplyDeleteI am one of those rare birds who loves heartbreaking movies. Strange as it sounds, I prefer tearjerkers to comedies...crying in films to laughing in them. So this movie is right up my alley, as is Lana's "Imitation of Life." (Though I actually prefer the original Claudette Colbert version of that film.) I agree, Lana's dramatic abilities shine in such films.
DeleteTo be perfectly content, all I need is a Sunday afternoon, a box of chocolates, this version of "Madame X" and a box of tissues. My husband told me he once caught his mom bawling her eyes out over this movie. It must be a chick thing.
ReplyDeleteGladys George is outstanding in the 1937 version of "Madame X". The 1929 version has a good performance from Ruth Chatterton, but the movie itself creaks. There is an 80s TV movie starring Tuesday Weld that changes the son to a daughter. It worked fine.
Caftan Woman, that is my idea of a great Sunday afternoon as well, except I'll take a bag of potato chips AND of a box of chocolates.
DeleteThanks for the heads-up about the 80's TV movie. I'm going to look for that, as well as the Gladys George version. With both you and Artman warning that the '29 version is unbearably slow, I think I will skip that one.
This sounds like a terrific film! I'm not wild about every Lana Turner role, but sometimes she can be amazing (e.g. "The Bad and the Beautiful"). This sounds like a must-see film. Thanks for reviewing.
ReplyDeleteLana WAS amazing in "The Bad and the Beautiful," wasn't she? It's not a favorite of her films by any means, but I thought she was terrific, not to mention stunningly beautiful!
DeleteOhhh, I want her suit, fur and handbag in the second photo so very much. We're getting hit with snow again here this week (not at all common for this area during the second half of February), and I think an outfit like that would be marvelous for keeping the late winter chill at Bay.
ReplyDeleteWonderful review as always, dear Patti - I'd take your opinion on a film over any famous movie critic any day! :)
♥ Jessica
Oh, Jessica, I agree, Lana's suit, fur, and handbag are, indeed, lovely. Actually, her wardrobe during the entire "Holly Anderson, Aspiring Politician's Wife" part of the film is stunning. Every gown she wore, I was oohing and aahing and thinking, "Yes, please." (Just like that gorgeous coat you posted on your blog yesterday!!)
DeleteThank you so much for your very kind words. I do love sharing my thoughts and opinion about these great films.
Patti, Madame X, sounds like a wonderful soap opera film. Being a Lana Turner fan, I will have to check it out.
ReplyDeleteDawn,on DVD, it comes as part of a Lana Turner double feature, with "Portrait in Black" being the other film. And it's not that expensive...either $14.99 or $19.99 for the 2-film collection (at Barnes & Noble).
DeleteI can't say whether I've seen this but, being that it's a 60's movie, I probably haven't. I may have seen the older one though. As much as I avoid 60's movies, this one would be a good exception because I love Lana!
ReplyDeleteVictoria, you know I don't lean to 60's movies either, but as I said, this is my favorite film of that decade. For a Lana lover, "Madame X" is a must-see! It's got to be her most incredible performance...it's definitely her most heart-wrenching.
DeleteHey, Patti, I watched this film last year and liked it a lot. Many people in the room where crying a lot!
ReplyDeleteIn IMDb there are 10 different films listed as Madam X. I'm particularly interested in the 1929 version, with Lewis Stone, that is the same story, but with different character names.
Kisses!
Wow, 10 different Madame X's! Who knew it was made over that many times! I'm guessing the Lewis Stone version you are looking for is the one also with Ruth Chatterton, the one Caftan Woman and Artman have said is quite slow. I wonder if any of the versions you see in IMDB are silents? Just out of curiosity, I'm going to take a look.
Delete